Part A- This part was the easier part of the assignment. I
did not realize how much I liked to talk until I was unable to! With me not
being able to speaking, that forced my partner to do all the talking. She was
the one asking all the questions and changing the topic whenever needed to. It
got very hard when she was asking complex questions. So what she did instead
was she made those hard questions into much easier questions to answer; she
tried using yes or no questions. My partner was definitely in control of the
whole conversation and held the power. She was the one who asked the questions,
changed the topics when necessary, and changed the way we communicated by
asking certain types of questions. In cultures where there is no talking, they
would be treated differently and held to a lower standard than those who speak.
Also, it would make people who speak not want to interact with the other
culture. For example, people who are deaf use sing language. However, so many
people do not know sign language, which makes it very difficult with people who
speak communicate with them. People speak to each other every day, but we do
not value how fortunate we are to be able to do so.
Part B- This part was by far the hardest part of the
assignment. Not being able to have any body movements showed that there was
almost no point to the conversation because my partner was the one doing all
the work. My partner asked all the questions and did not get any answers she
needed out of me due to the lack of body motion. This made her very frustrated
and mad at me! Body language is
extremely necessary to use in a conversation. Without it there is no way to
have emotion or to show reaction without it. Conversations become very boring
and robotic.
People who may experience difficulty with body language are people with
autism. They are in a world
that is centered around themselves and when someone makes gesture or hand
motion, it is lost to them. Most autistic children have a hard time making eye
contact during conversation. When someone who does not have autism is speaking
to someone who does, not having eye contact would be difficult to see if you
are making sense to them because their attention could be somewhere else.
The benefit of
possessing the ability to read body language is such an advantage to life. For
example, if you are on a date with someone, you can tell I that person is
having a good time or not by their facial expressions and by their body
language. Many conversations that lead to relationships begin because interest
in communicated or some sort of body language, like a smile, a wink, a nod,
etc. Another example would be if you are working at a convenient store. If a
robber were to come in holding a gun, you can tell if they have done this
before or not by their body language. If they are shaky, continuously looking
around, sweating, and the look of being scared in their eyes. Being able to
read body language is a huge advantage.
For the most part, most people can read body language because it is
something we do every day. I think a situation where not reading body language
would be okay is if you travel to another country. There are so many different
cultures out there that live and act in so many different ways. If I were to
travel to Europe, they may act differently than I do here in America. You do
not want to confuse yourself. Another example would be playing poker. When playing
card games, you want to try and trick others by giving them false body language
and false facial expressions. In this case, not being able to read body
language would be a good thing because you may be telling yourself different
things that can confuse yourself.
In general, very good discussion on your first experiment. Good detail provided to your reader and good analysis on the issue of power in the conversation. I agree with the real life example you provided of how deaf people are treated in our culture. The only point missing is in reference to the issue of communicating complex ideas. Which culture would be better able to explain the concept of natural selection or Einstein's theory of relativity? Would we even be able to do science without symbolic language?
ReplyDeleteIt is very common for partners to express irritation and even anger in the second experiment. Some have even walked out! It is worth asking why they respond that way. It reflects discomfort with the conversation and we need to ask what is missing from the conversation that would make them uncomfortable? More on this point later...
Sections are a little out of order after that. I can't find were you discuss the information we get from body language. You discuss this a bit in the third section regarding benefits, but you are only considering the situation where body language matches and supports the information you receive from spoken language. What does it tell you when the body language doesn't match the spoken language? Humans tend to use body language as a type of lie detector. If spoken words don't match with the body language, we are more inclined to believe the body language and doubt the words. Think about how being able to detect liars might help an individual's ability to survive and reproduce. This goes back to the situation of your partner getting angry with you in this experiment. She wasn't getting the information she needed to figure out if you were telling the truth or not. This makes humans very uncomfortable, enough to make them want to escape from the conversation.
Yes, those with autism do have great difficulty reading body language.
Yes, different cultures use different systems of body language, so you may get misleading information from natives in other countries until you learn how to read their body language. Well done.
I agree with you on the part about autistic people. I can tell you from experience that it can get very frustrating trying to communicate with them. But it seems like you already know that.
ReplyDeleteThis activity was so difficult not being able to use words in one part, and not being able to move in the other. It definitely gives the other participant more control and power, as they were the ones that had to keep a long conversation going. I wrote about movement the same as you did. We use our facial expressions and our movement as a way of flirting. How hard would that be if we couldn't just our hands, make faces, and change the tone of our voices?
ReplyDelete